Ana Gasteyer has been cast in the Broadway musical “Schmigadoon!” at the Nederlander Theatre in New York City.
The casting brings a high-profile comedic talent to a production that has already garnered significant critical attention. Gasteyer, a former Saturday Night Live alum and Tony nominee [1], transitions from television comedy to a theatrical role that allows her to explore a different side of her performance range.
According to casting announcements made in February 2026 [3], Gasteyer will play a villainous character. Gasteyer said the nature of the role is "very mean which is very fun" [2]. This departure from her typical comedic personas suggests a more antagonistic presence on the stage.
Gasteyer said the opportunity represents a personal milestone in her career. She said that she finally feels embraced by Broadway [1], explaining that the role allowed her to pursue a dream she had previously been afraid to name.
The production itself has seen substantial success. “Schmigadoon!” is a 12-time Tony-nominated musical [4], cementing its place as a major fixture of the current Broadway season. Gasteyer's addition to the cast follows her first Tony nomination [1], marking a peak in her professional relationship with the New York theater scene.
The role is situated within a production known for its satirical take on musical theater tropes. By casting a seasoned improviser and sketch comedian, the production leans into the comedic timing necessary for the show's specific brand of humor.
“"I'm very mean which is very fun."”
Gasteyer's transition into a villainous Broadway role signifies a strategic pivot for the performer, moving from the ensemble-driven comedy of SNL to a centered, character-driven theatrical presence. For the production, adding a Tony nominee with Gasteyer's comedic pedigree helps maintain the momentum of a show that has already achieved significant industry recognition through 12 Tony nominations.
