The first-person puzzle adventure Call of the Elder Gods has launched on PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and Nintendo Switch 2 [1, 2].
As a sequel to Call of the Sea, the title attempts to expand a specific niche of atmospheric, Lovecraftian storytelling. Its reception highlights a divide between players who value mechanical puzzle design and those seeking a more cohesive narrative.
Alessandro Fillari of IGN said the game wonderfully captures the otherworldly tone and sense of mystery of its predecessor [1]. He said the title is an especially touching sequel [1]. This perspective aligns with a review from Dualshockers, which said the game is a charming trip through the Lovecraft mythos with great puzzles [1].
Other critics were less impressed with the writing. A reviewer from ComicBook.com said incredible puzzles save this bland Eldritch story [1]. That same reviewer said the game's many flaws outweigh its puzzle design [1]. Metro said the experience is a puzzling Lovecraftian mystery [1].
The game is developed by Out of the Blue Games and is available via Steam and Epic Games Store on PC [1, 2]. While the atmospheric quality is praised, the disparity in reviews suggests the game may struggle to satisfy players who prioritize plot over gameplay mechanics.
“"Call of the Elder Gods wonderfully captures the otherworldly tone and sense of mystery of its predecessor."”
The polarized reception of Call of the Elder Gods indicates a tension between the game's technical execution and its narrative depth. While the puzzle mechanics are widely accepted as a strength, the mixed feedback on the story suggests that the sequel may not have evolved its writing to match the atmospheric success of the original title.
