Union Minister Piyush Goyal demanded an apology from Rahul Gandhi in the Lok Sabha after Gandhi alleged police fired on student protesters.
The confrontation highlights the deepening divide between the governing party and the opposition over the handling of civil unrest and the accuracy of information shared within India's highest legislative body.
Goyal said that the allegations regarding police firing were fictitious and described the statements as a "bundle of lies" [1]. He said that no police firing occurred during the student demonstrations [2]. According to Goyal, the number of firing incidents during these protests was zero [2].
The minister said that these false claims harm the government's welfare initiatives. He called for the immediate removal of the remarks from the official Lok Sabha records to prevent the spread of misinformation within the parliamentary archive [1].
During the session in New Delhi, Goyal questioned the nature of the allegations being leveled by the opposition. He said the claims lacked factual basis and served only to mislead the public about the state of student protests [2].
Rahul Gandhi has not yet issued a formal response to the demand for an apology or the request to strike the comments from the record [1].
“"a bundle of lies"”
This clash underscores a recurring pattern in Indian parliamentary proceedings where the validity of opposition claims is aggressively contested by the treasury benches. By demanding the removal of remarks from the official record, the government is seeking to prevent these allegations from becoming established parliamentary precedent, while simultaneously framing the opposition as unreliable sources of information regarding domestic security and police conduct.


![Gottlieb, William P., 1917-, photographer. [Portrait of Billie Holiday and Mister, Downbeat, New York, N.Y., ca. Feb. 1947] 1 negative : b&w ; 2 1/4 x 2 1/4 in. Notes: Gottlieb Collection Assignme](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bf/Portrait_of_Billie_Holiday_and_Mister%2C_Downbeat%2C_New_York%2C_N.Y.%2C_ca._Feb._1947_%28LOC%2C_5020400274%2C_cropped%29.jpg)
