NBC Sports analyst Robbie Mustoe has released his selection for the best XI of the 2025-26 Premier League season.
The selection provides an expert evaluation of the individual performances that defined the English top flight over the last year. By identifying the most impactful players, the list serves as a benchmark for player valuation and seasonal success.
Mustoe said his analysis in May 2026 after the conclusion of the 38-match [1] campaign. The curated team was presented via the "The 2 Robbies Podcast" on NBC Sports, where Mustoe said the specific contributions that earned players a spot in his lineup.
The 2025-26 [2] season featured a rigorous schedule that tested the depth and consistency of every squad in the league. Mustoe's selection process focused on standout performers who maintained high levels of play throughout the duration of the competition.
While the official league awards often rely on a combination of voting and statistics, Mustoe's Best XI offers a tactical perspective on how these players influenced the game. His analysis highlights the intersection of individual brilliance, and team achievement within the English system.
This curated list arrives as teams begin to evaluate their rosters for the next transfer window. The inclusion of specific players in a high-profile Best XI can influence market demand, and contract negotiations for the athletes involved.
“Robbie Mustoe has released his selection for the best XI of the 2025-26 Premier League season.”
The release of a curated Best XI by a major broadcaster like NBC Sports creates a narrative of success that often precedes official end-of-season awards. Because these selections highlight the most consistent performers across a 38-game stretch, they provide a blueprint for which players are likely to command higher transfer fees or be targeted by other top-tier European clubs during the summer window.
